April 3, 2025 | Ethan Vestby

NASCAR's Most Controversial Moments


The Red States’ Favorite Sport Is Full Of Drama

A lot of people turn up their noses at NASCAR, but as a sport that’s been around for decades and decades, it’s definitely accumulated a lot of drama over the years. Much of this comes down to drivers’ behavior or how races are called. Let’s take a look.

Nascarcontroversies-Msn

Number 3 Car

Can you retire a number in sports? That’s a good question, as so much of competitive sports is about legacy, in which numbers play an important role. After all, just think of Wayne Gretzky’s 99 or Michael Jordan’s 23—or Dale Earnhardt’s number 3 car.

NASCAR champion Dale Earnhardt in the No. 3 carDarryl Moran, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Number 3 Car

The legacy of Dale Earnhardt's death comes down in part to his perishing on the track, which led to his number being retired from NASCAR. Driver Austin Dillon was given the number at the 2014 Dayton 500, but his triumphant clinching of the pole position was met with a mixed reaction from fans who resented him being given the number.

Dale Earnhardt, Chevrolet Lumina The No. 3 car, Michigan International SpeedwayJames Phelps, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

The 2008 Brickyard 400

NASCAR is a considerably large industry, and in turn, depends on a lot of moving parts to be a successful operation. So, if something like the tires on the cars are faulty, you can see everything potentially start to crumble.

Screenshot of the video 2008 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Brickyard 400 @ Indianapolis | Full Race2008 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Brickyard 400 @ Indianapolis | Full Race, Voti

The 2008 Brickyard 400

The 2008 Brickyard 400 race at that year’s Indianapolis 500 saw faulty tires from Goodyear slow down the competition due to constant pitstops. Always investing in infrastructure is the lesson learned, as NASCAR is so dependent on being the fastest sport out there.

Screenshot of the video 2008 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Brickyard 400 @ Indianapolis | Full Race2008 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Brickyard 400 @ Indianapolis | Full Race, Voti

Advertisement

Danica Patrick’s Pole Win

Danica Patrick broke the glass ceiling in the world of racing, but naturally, that upset a number of sexist NASCAR fans. Her triumphant pole win at the 2013 Daytona 500 triggered a large wave of negativity.

Danica Patrick drives the No. 10 Chevrolet through the garageMarco Becerra, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Danica Patrick’s Pole Win

Conspiracy theorists tried to discredit Patrick’s achievement, asserting that it was all a publicity stunt. Nothing concrete had ever been proven by them though, and her accomplishment remains a considerable landmark.

Danica Patrick driving the driver's parade on the Phoenix International SpeedwayMorrison_2001, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Richard Petty’s Almost 200th Win

Big-deal American sports like baseball or football have been plagued with controversies about cheating in recent decades. If you need examples, just look at “Deflategate” with the New England Patriots or the number of steroid scandals amongst Major League Baseball sluggers. And of course, NASCAR has had its own cheating scandals.

Portrait Photo of American stock car driver Richard PettyTed Van Pelt, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Richard Petty’s Almost 200th Win

NASCAR driver Richard Petty was a similar source of controversy, in particular due to his win at the 1983 Charlotte Motor Speedway where his car had both an oversized engine and illegal tires. It pointed to a double standard, as racer Tim Richmond was fined and docked points for the same reason, but Petty got away scot-free.

The Petty Enterprises STP Pontiac of The King Richard Pettyus44mt, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

SpinGate

An event deemed “SpinGate” at the 2013 Federated Auto Parts 400 rocked the world of NASCAR. The reason being that it seemed to reveal new levels of cheating possible with the sport.

Clint Bowyer wearing a black cap and a pair of sunglassesZach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

SpinGate

At the race, The Michael Waltrip Racing Team had one of its drivers, Clint Bowyer, spin his car in order to draw a flag, thus stopping the momentum of the race and benefiting his teammate, Martin Truex Jr. The dirty tricks employed by the team were noticed though, which resulted in the team seeing sanctions and Truex Jr being banned from a future race.

Martin Truex Jr. at Talladega SuperspeedwayZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dale Earnhardt And Terry Labonte Face Off

Giving your opponent a body check in hockey is one thing, but in NASCAR, hitting someone with your car is a whole other ballgame. Racing legend Dale Earnhardt wasn’t above this kind of foul play.

Screenshot of the video NASCAR Classic Full Race: Dale Earnhardt rattles Terry Labonte's cageNASCAR Classic Full Race: Dale Earnhardt rattles Terry Labonte's cage, NASCAR

Dale Earnhardt And Terry Labonte Face Off

During a race at the 1999 Bristol Motor Speedway, Earnhardt and fellow driver Terry Labonte were neck and neck when the former pulled the dirty move of deliberately bumping into the latter’s rear, causing a crash. Earnhardt stated he didn’t mean for that to happen, but some don’t believe it to this day.

Screenshot of the video NASCAR Classic Full Race: Dale Earnhardt rattles Terry Labonte's cageNASCAR Classic Full Race: Dale Earnhardt rattles Terry Labonte's cage, NASCAR

Kevin Harvick 2020

Do you remember that song by one-hit wonder New Radicals entitled “You Get What You Give”? Well, that title certainly means a lot, especially when it comes to NASCAR racer Kevin Harvick.

Kevin Harvick at Dover Motor SpeedwayZach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Kevin Harvick 2020

Harvick was on top of the NASCAR world in 2020, being far away the most successful racer in the league. Trailing in the penultimate race of the season, he panicked and spun driver Kyle Busch, yet it only resulted in Harvick crashing into a wall.

Kevin Harvick at ISM RacewayZach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Logano Legacy

In 2018, at Martinsville Speedway, Joey Logano had his sights set on overtaking superstar Martin Truex Jr, which led to him employing aggressive driving that resulted in both cars sliding. Logano won, securing a spot in the Championship 4, while Truex vowed in his post-race interview that Logano was going down.

Joey Logano wearing sunglassesZach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Logano Legacy

Truex didn’t get his revenge in the subsequent championship-deciding race though, with Logano triumphing. It seems like he was sending a message that playing dirty could pay off, unfortunately.

Joey Logano at Dover International SpeedwayZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Johnson Versus Larson

Jimmie Johnson is undeniably a legend of NASCAR, but even legends can get insecure as they see the dying of the light. A 2018 race at the Charlotte ROVAL saw a last gasp at glory that didn’t turn out well.

Jimmie Johnson wearing a black jumpsuit at Bristol Motor SpeedwayZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Johnson Versus Larson

It was time for the Millennial driver Kyle Larson to see glory, though, capitalizing off Johnson making the cocky mistake of out-braking another driver and spinning out of control. Larson won the race and Johnson never competed in the playoffs again.

Kyle Larson's No. 42 DC Solar/Credit One Bank ChevroletZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Carl Edwards’ Early Retirement

Walking away when glory is still ahead of you is a complicated decision as, after all, does it come down to knowing what’s actually best or just being afraid of pursuing greatness? That question arises with the legacy of driver Carl Edwards.

Carl Edwards at the 2012 Kobalt Tools 400Brian Neudorff, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Carl Edwards’ Early Retirement

Edwards was considered a rising star in NASCAR, but after a near-death experience at the 2016 Homestead race in Miami, he realized there was more to life than racing cars. He soon announced his retirement and decision to focus on family, as it seemed he realized how precious life was.

Carl Edwards' No. 19 Stanley Tools Toyota at Sonoma RacewayTaurusEmerald, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Matt Kenseth Is Hunting You Down

In the fall of 2015, at Kansas Speedway, Joey Logano spun driver Matt Kenseth out of the race lead, ending Kenseth's playoff run and securing Logano's spot in the Round of 8—though it created a bitter rivalry. Kenseth later retaliated by intentionally wrecking Logano as he lapped him, sending Logano into the wall and out of the playoffs.

Matt Kenseth at Texas Motor SpeedwayRaniel Diaz, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Matt Kenseth Is Hunting You Down

Kenseth was suspended for his actions, but fans felt otherwise and cheered the dramatic showdown. The incident paved the way for Jeff Gordon to win his 93rd and final NASCAR Cup race that day.

Kenseth at the 2015 NASCAR Victory Lap eventTomás Del Coro, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Bad Boys

The inaugural Nationwide Series race in 2007 saw a lot of drama, as Robby Gordon made the overly aggressive move of knocking race leader Marcos Ambrose off the track while he was restarting. Despite being shown a black flag, Gordon didn’t leave the track and went about celebrating false victory.

Robby Gordon at the Dakar RallyEmanuel Agustin Lorenzoni Macchi, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Bad Boys

Gordon’s behavior saw a $35,000 fine which he had to suffer on top of the embarrassment of celebrating a false victory. NASCAR drives can succumb to some of the worst cockiness known to man.

Robby Gordon racing at Martinsville SpeedwayMatt and Cyndi Maxson, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

The Loose Wheel

The first year of NASCAR’s new playoff format was an exciting one, particularly the race that saw Kurt Busch leading until the 94th lap, where he was forced to make a pitstop due to a loose wheel. But before even that could happen, the right front wheel detached from the car, narrowly missing the attenuator and triggering an immediate caution flag that kept him on the lead lap.

Kurt Busch wearing a black capZach Catanzareti Photo, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Loose Wheel

After dropping to 28th, he and his crew seized the opportunity provided by the caution, fighting their way back through the field over the final 150 laps. If the wheel had come off slightly later, the outcome might have been different, but Busch ultimately claimed the first-ever Chase for the Cup title in a triumphant comeback.

Kurt Busch's car that won the 2017 Daytona 500Todd Van Hoosear, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Regan Smith And The Yellow Line

Underdog Regan Smith achieving a surprising victory at Talladega Superspeedway was deeply inspiring to fans. Sadly, officials ended up making the call that Smith had driven out of bounds by dipping his left-side tires below the yellow line in the final half-mile of the 2008 Amp Energy 500, declaring Tony Stewart the winner instead.

Regan Smith, Chevrolet crosses the finishline with Tony StewartChris Graythen, Getty Images

Regan Smith And The Yellow Line

Smith contended that Stewart, to maintain his lead, had forced him below the line, sparking controversy over the ruling. The call was controversial, being that in the past, officials had allowed Dale Earnhardt Jr a victory after a similar finish.

Regan Smith at ISM RacewayZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

2008 LifeLock 400

Dale Earnhardt Jr's victory at the 2008 LifeLock 400 was a surprisingly seminal moment in NASCAR history, at least in terms of setting rules. It seems like he was just being a smart driver, but the officials saw it as maybe a little too clever.

Earnhardt addresses the media at Hendrick Motorsports headquartersMike R. Smith, Wikimedia Commons

2008 LifeLock 400

During one of the cautions in the race, Earnhardt used the strategy of turning off his engine to save gas, allowing his car to coast and nearly stop before restarting it to regain speed. Barely winning with the gas he had left, NASCAR soon implemented a rule that all cars maintain a consistent speed set by the pace car during such periods.

Earnhardt Jr. and the No. 83 NAVY ChevroletAndrea Ross, Wikimedia Commons

Chrome Bumper

Before the 1982 Daytona 500, Bobby Allison's race team practiced using a car lacking a rear bumper. During the main event, a routine bump-drafting nudge caused the bumper to detach, and Allison proceeded to dominate and win the race.

Screenshot of the video 1982 Daytona 500 from Daytona International Speedway | NASCAR Classic1982 Daytona 500 from Daytona International Speedway, NASCAR Classics

Advertisement

Chrome Bumper

Engineers later discovered that removing the rear bumper significantly reduced aerodynamic drag, resulting in a speedier car. Despite Allison and his crew denying misconduct on their end, NASCAR officials made sure for future races to implement heavy chrome bumpers made from lighter plastic and fiberglass.

Screenshot of the video 1982 Daytona 500 from Daytona International Speedway | NASCAR Classic1982 Daytona 500 from Daytona International Speedway, NASCAR Classic

1959 Daytona 500

Sports often employ the term “photo finish” and this was very much the case at the inaugural Daytona 500 in 1959. It was a nail-biter that came down to racers Lee Petty and Johnny Beauchamp, with fans of each justifiably claiming one won.

Winner Lee Petty (No. 42) edges his Oldsmobile past the Ford Thunderbird of Johnny Beauchamp (No. 73)RacingOne, Getty Images

1959 Daytona 500

Beauchamp was initially declared the winner by only 10 inches, but Petty contested, and it wasn’t until three days later that a photo from a track photographer showed otherwise. NASCAR reversed the call and made Petty the new victor, so his legacy owes a lot to advances in technology.

NASCAR Nextel Cup SeriesRacingOne, Getty Images

Advertisement

Video Replay

The 2011 Nationwide Series race at Road America was evidence of how increasingly important video replay was to motorsport, as much as it was to, say, football when determining a touchdown. Racer Reed Sorenson was sure he had won, and just needed to be patient to be affirmed.

NASCAR driver Ron Fellowsl racing his stock car at Road AmericaRoyalbroil, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Video Replay

At first, it seemed Ron Fellows had won the race, but Sorenson contested that he only took the lead after he had slowed for the caution flag, prompting NASCAR to issue a review. After originally awarding the victory to Fellows, NASCAR reversed the decision, asserting Sorenson was ahead when the caution lights activated.

Reed Sorenson at Talladega SuperspeedwayZach Catanzareti, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

2004 Talladega

In 2004, Jeff Gordon and Dale Earnhardt Jr were the two biggest racers in NASCAR. Of course, in the world of sports, being at the top always implies bitter rivalry, even more between fans than the actual players.

Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s NASCAR carEagle Shooter, CC BY 2.0 Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

2004 Talladega

At the 2004 Talladega race, this all came to a head when a crash on the track caused the race to freeze, and led to a video replay of who won—Gordon or Earnhardt Jr. Gordon was deemed the winner despite contrary evidence, which led to angry fans chucking beers on the track.

Screenshot of the video Jeff Gordon Career Win #65 2004 Aarons 499 at TalladegaJeff Gordon Career Win #65 2004 Aarons 499 at Talladega, Jeff Gordon Edits

Shameful History

The 1963 Jacksonville Speedway Park race pointed to professional racing’s problematic history with African American drivers. The Black driver Wendell Scott seemed to be the rightful winner of the race, but Buck Baker was declared the victor instead to seemingly prevent racist fan backlash during the height of the civil rights movement.

Wendell Scott poses for a portrait in his car as he became the first African-American driver to win in the NASCAR Cup divisionRacingOne, Getty Images

Shameful History

Yet 45 minutes after the race, the result was rectified after Scott made sure to protest. Declared the victor, what’s additionally shameful behind his moment of glory being taken away in front of fans is that he’s to date still the only Black winner of a NASCAR Cup Series race.

You May Also Like: 

Formula One's Biggest Rivalries

Brilliant NASCAR Drivers Who Died On The Track

The Most Memorable And Bizarre NASCAR “Firsts”

A replica of Wendell Scott's No. 34 1962 ChevroletMike Kalasnik, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Source: 1 2 3


READ MORE

Dale Internal

The Day Dale Earnhardt Died

Dale Earnhardt, or Dale Sr., was a professional stock car racer from North Carolina. In his 25+ year career, he came to be known as one of the greatest NASCAR racers in the history of the sport. But his sudden death surprised everyone—and his autopsy in particular became hugely controversial.
July 13, 2024 Tom Miller

The History and Evolution Of The American RV

RVs or Recreational Vehicles have become an integral part of the American culture.
August 20, 2024 Marlon Wright

40 Coolest Cars Of The 2000s

The year 2000 was the start of a new millennium—and some of the coolest cars around.
September 19, 2024 Jack Hawkins

The Cars With The Longest Production Runs Of All-Time

These cars have enjoyed long and storied production runs, but this everyday driver eclipsed the lot with astonishing longevity.
September 18, 2024 Jack Hawkins

These American Cars Were Only Produced For One Year

Most American cars are offered year-after-year, with minor (or major) upgrades provided—but these rare beauties were only offered for one single year of production.
September 23, 2024 Jack Hawkins

People With The Largest Car Collections In The World

Everyone has their vice: the thing they spend all their money on. For these people, it's cars. All kinds of cars. Here are the people with the largest car collections in the world.
September 25, 2024 Jack Hawkins