November 25, 2024 | Peter Kinney

You Can Usually Skip These Overrated Car Repairs


Skip These Services

Every repair shop has a list of "recommended" services that they insist your car needs. But does it really? Here are some frequent unnecessary common car repairs that might be emptying your wallet without providing much benefit.

Car Repair

Premium Fuel For Regular Cars

Premium fuel is said to have an octane rating between 91 and 94, while regular fuel is around 87. The higher octane in premium helps it avoid knocking, which is basically when the fuel burns too early. This is important for high-performance engines.

Premium FuelEkaterina Belinskaya, Pexels

Advertisement

Premium Fuel For Regular Cars (Cont.)

Conducted tests have shown that using premium fuel might give your car a minimal boost in horsepower or fuel efficiency. But honestly, those improvements are usually so minor that they don't make the higher price worth it for most cars. 

Premium FuelRDNE Stock project/Pexels

Cat-Back Exhaust System

One of the most notable changes with a cat-back system is the increase in exhaust noise, which can be annoying to some. While cat-back systems also promise increased horsepower, the gains are often small, typically ranging from 5 to 15 HP. 

https://www.pexels.com/photo/a-woman-with-headscarf-filling-up-the-gas-tank-4911488/ Cat-Back Exhaust SystemHow To: Install a CatBack Exhaust System by Luca Car Mods

Cat-Back Exhaust System (Cont.)

A lot of aftermarket cat-back exhaust systems can actually weigh more than the original parts. This extra weight can offset a certain amount of the performance gains you get from better exhaust flow, especially if you've got a smaller or lighter car. 

Cat-Back Exhaust System2015-2023 6.4L HEMI Challenger MBRP Cat-Back Exhaust with Carbon Fiber Tips Review & Sound Clip by AmericanMuscle Dodge

Advertisement

Headlight Upgrades

Not every vehicle can easily handle secondary market headlight upgrades. Some might need extra tweaks or wiring changes, which can make the installation trickier and raise the costs. Incorrect wiring can also result in fatal electrical issues or malfunctioning lights.

Headlight UpgradesChanging a Car Headlight : Change a Car Headlight by ExpertVillage Leaf Group

Headlight Upgrades (Cont.)

Switching to modern lights like LEDs or HID (High-Intensity Discharge) might give you a brighter, more concentrated beam. But then, many cars already have quite good lighting for regular driving situations. Some drivers just upgrade their headlights for aesthetics.

Headlight UpgradesMatheus Bertelli, Pexels

Spark Plug Replacement At Short Intervals

Modern spark plugs, especially those made from iridium or platinum, tend to last longer than the old copper ones by a long shot. Companies like Toyota and DENSO recommend replacement intervals of up to 100,000 miles for these advanced spark plugs.

Spark PlugSpark Plug Replacement DIY (the ULTIMATE Guide) by ChrisFix

Advertisement

Spark Plug Replacement At Short Intervals (Cont.)

Many service schedules mix time-based intervals with mileage suggestions, such as suggesting service every 60 months. This can be a tad confusing, especially for cars that don't get driven much and might not seriously wear down their spark plugs over time.

Spark PlugSpark Plug Replacement DIY (the ULTIMATE Guide) by ChrisFix

Coolant Flush

This is a maintenance procedure wherein you remove the old coolant from a vehicle's cooling system and replace it with a fresh one. However, if low-quality coolant is added after a flush, it might not give proper protection against corrosion or overheating.

Coolant FlushHow to Quick Flush Your Cars Cooling System by ChrisFix

Coolant Flush (Cont.)

When drivers are told they need a coolant flush, it's because they're dealing with issues like overheating or their car just not running well. But sometimes, these problems can actually come from other things, such as a broken thermostat or leaks in the radiator.

Coolant FlushHow to Quick Flush Your Cars Cooling System by ChrisFix

Advertisement

Brake Fluid Flush

In older cars with significant built-up in the brakes, flushing the system tends to release debris that might clog other parts, like the calipers or ABS modules. Also, newer vehicles come equipped with advanced braking systems that are made to be less prone to moisture absorption.

Brake Fluid FlushHere is How to TEST and FLUSH brake fluid without removing wheels/one man brake fluid change by AliMECH

Fuel Injector Cleaning Services

Modern fuel injection systems do a good job of cleaning themselves. Each injector nozzle works at high pressure and sprays fuel through tiny holes that are a few inches wide. Plus, quality gasoline has up to five times more detergent than the EPA requires.

Fuel Injector Cleaning ServicesHow To Clean Fuel Injection Systems - Fuel Injector Service - OTC 7448 by The Car Doctor

Fuel Injector Cleaning Services (Cont.)

In case your car's running rough, hesitating, or misfiring, it might need a clean, but you could just try an affordable bottle of quality cleaner first. Getting a professional cleaning can set you back $150-300, and it usually doesn't help much, to be honest.

Fuel Injector Cleaning ServicesFuel Injection cleaning in less than 5 Minutes/HOW TO clean injection Directly without disassembling by AliMECH

Advertisement

Battery Replacements

Don't rush to replace your battery just because it's three or four years old. Nowadays, batteries can last anywhere from 5 to 7 years if you take care of them. Regular tests, such as Voltage or Load, give you an idea of its health rather than going by age. 

Battery Easy Process to Change the Battery on your Car by Got it done!

Battery Replacements (Cont.)

Hot weather can drain the battery life, while cooler temps can help it operate longer. If your car is slow to start, then you definitely should check its battery. But remember, some aftermarket options do not offer the same reliability or lifespan as original ones.

BatteryDaniel Andraski, Pexels

Unnecessary Oil Additives

According to Machinery Lubrication, if you choose high-quality lubricants from reputable manufacturers, additional additives often give little to no benefit and can sometimes even detract from the oil's performance. For most everyday drivers, premium oils are sufficient for engine health.

Oil AdditivesDaniel Andraski, Pexels

Advertisement

Unnecessary Oil Additives (Cont.)

Adding secondary market oil additives can negatively affect the carefully balanced formulation of the oil, leading to adverse effects. For example, increasing the concentration of one type of additive might improve a specific property while degrading another.

Oil AdditivesDvortygirl, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Unnecessary Oil Additives (Cont.)

Relevant research has shown that certain additives can increase the viscosity of the oil beyond acceptable limits, which can impair cold-flow ability and the car's overall lubrication performance. These additives could essentially hinder engine operation.

Oil AdditivesMyke Waddy, Wikimedia Commons

Wheel Alignments

It's not mandatory to get your wheels aligned every time you change the tires. Once in a while, or after hitting a huge bump, it makes sense to get it done. TATA AIG suggests checking alignment every 10,000 miles or as specified by the vehicle's manufacturer.

Wheel AlignmentsJonathan Reynaga, Pexels

Advertisement

Radiator Cap Replacements

The radiator cap is a key part of your car's cooling system. It helps keep the right pressure and temperature to stop the engine from overheating. In discussions on Car Talk, mechanics have reported that they rarely replace radiator caps.

Radiator CapHow to Replace Radiator Cap 1992-1996 Toyota Camry 2.2L I4 by TRQ

Radiator Cap Replacements (Cont.)

They only do it if there is a specific problem linked to the cooling system. Radiator caps can be tested for pressure retention using specialized equipment, which provides a more accurate assessment of their condition without needing to replace them preemptively.

Radiator CapHow to Replace Radiator Cap 1992-1996 Toyota Camry 2.2L I4 by TRQ

Frequent Power Steering Flushes

Some sources recommend changing the power steering fluid every 30,000 to 50,000 miles as part of regular maintenance. Doing this helps clear out any particles or contaminants that build up over time. In turn, this keeps your car's power steering working smoothly.

Power Steering FlushesHow to Flush a Power Steering System -- EASY! By 2CarPros

Advertisement

Frequent Power Steering Flushes (Cont.)

For instance, the power steering fluid in a Toyota should be changed at least once every two years. Stiff steering or strange noise doesn't always mean the fluid needs changing. Those signs can come from other problems, like worn-out parts or leaks.

Power Steering FlushesHow to Flush a Power Steering System -- EASY! By 2CarPros

Frequent Power Steering Flushes (Cont.)

Now, suppose your power steering fluid looks dark or smells burnt; that's a clear sign it's gone bad and probably needs to be changed. Fresh power steering fluid should be fresh and clear, usually a bright red or pink color, depending on what type is being used.

Power Steering FlushesHow to Flush Your Power Steering Fluid by ChrisFix

Serpentine Belt Maintenance

Modern serpentine belts are often made from EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer) rubber, which is far more durable and resistant to heat, oil, and ozone than older materials. This allows them to last longer—often exceeding 100,000 miles under normal driving conditions.

Serpentine BeltHow To: Check & Change Your Vehicle's Serpentine Belt, Tensioner & Idler Pulley by O'Reilly Auto Parts

Advertisement

Serpentine Belt Maintenance (Cont.)

Rather than replacing serpentine belts solely based on mileage, a visual inspection can serve as a more accurate assessment of their condition. Drivers should regularly check for small fissures, space between the ribs, splits in the belt, or if the belt is constantly slipping. 

Serpentine BeltHow To Replace A Serpentine Belt by Mechanic Gone Rogue


READ MORE

White 2024 Tesla Model 3

An In-depth Look At The 2024 Tesla Model 3

Explore the future of electric vehicles with our in-depth review of the 2024 Tesla Model 3, delving into its impressive performance, cutting-edge technology, and luxurious comfort that continue to redefine automotive expectations.
August 1, 2023 Allison Robertson
White 2024 Tesla Model 3

An In-depth Look At The 2024 Tesla Model 3

Explore the future of electric vehicles with our in-depth review of the 2024 Tesla Model 3, delving into its impressive performance, cutting-edge technology, and luxurious comfort that continue to redefine automotive expectations.
September 28, 2023 Allison Robertson

10 Of The Best Electric Vehicles On The Market

Explore the top electric vehicles of 2023 across diverse price ranges. Dive deep into performance reviews of standout models like the BMW i4, Tesla Model 3, and Jaguar I-PACE. Whether luxury or budget-friendly, find the EV that fits your needs.
September 12, 2023 Sammy Tran

10 Of The Best Electric Vehicles On The Market

Explore the top electric vehicles of 2023 across diverse price ranges. Dive deep into performance reviews of standout models like the BMW i4, Tesla Model 3, and Jaguar I-PACE. Whether luxury or budget-friendly, find the EV that fits your needs.
October 10, 2023 Sammy Tran
Best New SUVs For Families

10 Of The Best New SUVs For Families

There are lots of great new SUVs on the market, but when it comes to deciding which is best for your family, safety is as important as comfort. To help you choose the best ride, we’ve looked at vehicles that are highly rated by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). We also went to the manufacturers themselves to compare details like prices and fuel efficiency.
May 22, 2024 Peter Kinney